transgender man who had given birth, but doesn’t want to be called a mother on
a birth certificate has lost a high court battle.
man named, Freddy McConnell, aged 32 was originally from Deal, Kent and wanted
to be registered as a father or parent.
A judge on September 25th ruled against his request after analyzing
the argument in a High Court trial in London.
Freddy McConnell, aged 32, wanted to be registered as a father or parent, but a Judge on September 25th ruled against his request after analyzing the argument in a High Court trial in London
President of the Family Division of the High Court, Sir Andrew McFarlane heard how Mr. McConnell is a single parent, born a woman and living as a man following several surgeries.
Biologically, Mr. McConnell was able to give birth but legally became a man was his child was born.
Freddy McConnell is a multimedia journalist who works for The Guardian
Mr. McConnell was fighting in the High Court to be recognized by the government as the child’s father and not mother
Mr. McConnell had started taking testosterone at age 25 and had breast tissue removal at age 26
register specifically told Mr. McConnell that the law required people who bore
children to be registered as ‘Mothers’
and not as ‘Father’ or ‘Parent.’
is a material difference between a person’s status as a parent and gender. Being
a mother whilst hitherto always associated with being female has been the
status granted to a person who experienced both the biological and physical
process of carrying a pregnancy and giving birth to a child.’ Sir Andrew
explained in a ruling.
Mr. McConnell was able to give birth naturally
Mr. McConnell reveals he feels a special bond with his son after giving birth
added: ‘While it is now legally and medically possible for any individual whose
gender is known in law as a Male to be become pregnant and give birth, their
parental status, derived from their biological role in giving birth to a child
is that of a ‘Mother.’
McConnell, is a multimedia journalist working for The Guardian. His lawyer,
Karen Holden, Founder of A City Law Firm revealed an appeal was being
Mr. McConnell during university days decided to begin his transition from woman to man but chose to keep his womb
After one failed attempt, Freddy got pregnant on his second try using a sperm donor
‘It was positive’
‘As a firm that fights for equality, we’re of course disappointed at the judgment made by the court and its highlights on how the law is too slow in keeping up with the modern trend,’ Karen stated.
Freddy stated he will be open with his son as he grows up about his ‘Motherhood’ journey
Nevertheless, Mr. McConnell had started taking testosterone at age 25 and had breast tissue removal at age 26. He never removed his uterus because he didn’t rule out not wanting children.